Smart & Final
Overcoming communication hurdles with digital solutions.
One of the oldest and longest continually operated food retailers in the United States, Smart & Final offers quality products in various sizes, saving customers time and money without a membership fee. But growth and success brought challenges that led the team to TraceGains solutions.
Communication struggles—inside & out
To better understand the company’s growing pains, we worked with Director of Quality Assurance Celia Workman.
At any given time, Smart & Final works with up to 300 manufacturers for its private label brands. This many collaborators creates significant paperwork, and Celia’s team has spent most of their time chasing down suppliers to receive the proper documentation.
“Many suppliers are hesitant to provide documentation,” Celia said. “However, we need it. Most suppliers understand the need, but vendors struggle to comply. So, I spent the majority of my time trying to convince our vendors that we need transparency.”
Obtaining the necessary documentation for regulatory compliance was a battle. Celia and her team relied on email and phone calls to communicate with suppliers, which was often inefficient and slow.
Internally, Celia’s team connected with other departments through meetings, emails, and voicemails. The team stored working files, like product specifications, as Word documents in shared drives that everyone could access, but this led to other problems.
“Everyone had access to the documents, so we’d find specifications missing or other issues, especially around version control,” Celia said. “Someone else would open the file, then put them back, and often something was revised or changed. There were specifications we’d put together, then they were gone, and my team or I would have to recreate the file.”
An unworkable solution
An unwieldy, big-name, bigger-budget PLM system made Celia’s already challenging job nearly impossible. Following a complicated implementation process that dragged on for more than a year, Celia fought to manage supplier documentation from the confines of a system that turned small tasks into time-consuming projects. Her suppliers disliked it, too.
The system was exceedingly slow and prone to crashes, which required users to start the painful process all over again.
“I was afraid to speak with vendors,” Celia recalled. “I tried to be patient because it took suppliers multiple hours to enter the data for a single product.”
Celia and her team needed “the latest and greatest version of supplier information, regulatory documents, and specifications in one place” that employees could access but not change without appropriate permission, approval, and tracking.
At one point, we went an entire year with the system not working properly. It crashed constantly. I can’t tell you how many times I reported the issue and demanded our money back.Celia Workman, Director of Quality Assurance
Implementing TraceGains Supplier Management with Networked Ingredients Marketplace
TraceGains makes supplier onboarding quick and easy for the Smart & Final team. When a new supplier is selected, the supplier receives an alert to submit all required supplier and ingredient documentation, such as annual audits, FDA facility registration information, or allergen, kosher and organic certifications. TraceGains automatically highlights risk by supplier, item, geography, and more, identifying the most critical threats, so Celia’s team can take action to prevent business disruption and other concerns.
“Before TraceGains, I ran a monthly query to learn which documents were going to expire, and then manually notify each vendor individually,” Celia said. “We’re a small team, and we have important business needs to address. We don’t have the time to babysit documents.”
Now, with TraceGains, Smart & Final’s suppliers receive automatic alerts if documents are missing, incomplete, or about to expire, so everything remains up to date. It also helped that most of Smart & Final’s suppliers were already on the TraceGains Network.
“We heard from many of our suppliers who were delighted with the transition to TraceGains. They especially appreciate PostOnce®, which allows suppliers to complete a document or provide information once and send it to all their customers with a single action. It’s a huge selling point for suppliers,” Celia pointed out.
Celia and her team frequently take advantage of Networked Ingredients Marketplace, TraceGains’ comprehensive sourcing directory for ingredients, items, packaging, and service providers. Advanced search criteria like country of origin, organic, non-GMO, kosher, and more delivers precise sourcing fast.
“We use Marketplace to find new suppliers when a vendor performs poorly, or our preferred vendors don’t carry an ingredient or item that we need. It saves us an enormous amount of time compared to how we had selected and onboarded vendors in the past. Just a few clicks and we’re connected, and we instantly have the documentation and information we need.”
Collaborating TraceGains Specification Management
Celia’s team also selected TraceGains Specification Management to create, publish, and update raw material and finished goods specifications on the TraceGains networked platform. When implemented, the team won’t have to worry about chasing down supplier, ingredient, or item details to build and update specifications because they’re already connected. They’ll be able to auto-populate configurable templates. It also allows the team to collaborate directly with suppliers to create and update specifications – a new approach that will let the team work faster while also improving quality.
Completing the digital transformation
TraceGains allows Celia’s team to digitize everything from allergen forms to certifications to specifications. This provides the team the data to power configurable dashboards and reports to determine compliance against label claims, nutrition targets, thresholds (like Prop 65), country of origin, and more.
“It really works,” Celia said. “It’s user-friendly and makes it easy for us to collaborate with suppliers and determine how they’re performing. Before, we didn’t have the colorful dashboard that we have now, thanks to TraceGains. It’s exciting that we can spot issues and track trends in real-time.”
Automation for the win
TraceGains Specification Management helps retailers like Smart & Final transform disconnected specification management steps into highly automated digital workflows. Teams can conduct real-time tasks alongside automated steps to improve consistency, eliminate errors, enable measurements, and vastly improve outcome reliability and quality. Find out how your team can save time and improve efficiency with our solutions.